Arizona law entitles you to compensation for injuries in an auto accident due to another’s negligence. The insurance company may help you cover your medical bills, lost income, vehicle damage, and other losses. However, insurance claims do not always go smoothly. An insurer may deny a claim, delay its investigation, dispute liability, or offer far less than your losses justify.
Dealing with an insurance dispute after a car accident can leave you wondering: “Can someone sue an insurance company after an auto accident in Arizona?”
The answer depends on the circumstances, including whether you are pursuing compensation from the at-fault driver’s insurer or making a claim under your own policy. Understanding your rights can help you decide whether to negotiate, file a regulatory complaint, or pursue litigation.
Can You Sue an Insurance Company After a Car Accident in Arizona?
In many Arizona auto accident cases, the injured person initially seeks compensation from the at-fault driver’s liability insurance. If the insurer refuses to make a fair settlement, the injured person often pursues legal action against the driver and not necessarily against the insurance company.
Different issues or disputes can arise even when making a claim under your own insurance policy. An insurance dispute might involve:
- A denied claim
- A disagreement over coverage
- A substantially inadequate settlement offer
- A dispute over the value of vehicle damage
- Unreasonable delays in handling a claim
- Disputes on the extent of accident-related injuries
Because these cases can involve both insurance law and personal injury law, it is important to have an attorney review the specific facts before deciding how to proceed.
When an Insurance Company May Be Acting Improperly
Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 20-461 identifies various unfair claim settlement practices. The prohibited practices include:
- Failing to respond reasonably and promptly to claim communications
- Failing to maintain reasonable standards for investigating claims
- Refusing to pay without any reasonable investigation
- Failing to make good-faith efforts to settle claims when liability has become reasonably clear
- Failing to provide a reasonable explanation for the basis of a claim denial or compromise settlement
However, an important distinction exists under Arizona law. A.R.S. § 20-461 expressly states that the statute does not itself create a private right of action for an insured or uninsured person. Instead, it provides an administrative remedy to the Arizona insurance regulator.
That means an insurer’s questionable conduct should not automatically be described as a lawsuit. An experienced Arizona attorney can evaluate whether other legal claims or remedies may apply to your particular situation.
What If the Insurance Company Makes a Low Settlement Offer?
One of the most common problems after a serious Tucson car accident is receiving a settlement offer that does not adequately reflect the person’s losses.
An insurance adjuster may focus on expenses that you have already incurred while overlooking future medical treatment or other consequences of the injury. Depending on the circumstances, compensation may include:
- Emergency and ongoing medical expenses
- Lost wages
- Reduced earning capacity
- Vehicle repair or replacement costs
- Out-of-pocket accident expenses
- Pain and suffering
- Other legally recoverable damages
You are not necessarily required to accept the insurer’s first offer. Before signing a settlement agreement, consider having a Tucson auto accident attorney review the offer. In essence, once you accept a settlement and sign a release, pursuing additional compensation can become significantly more difficult.
Steps to Take Before Suing an Insurance Company
If an insurer is disputing your claim, take steps to preserve evidence and protect your position.
- Keep Your Accident Records – Save the police report, photographs, videos, medical records, bills, repair estimates, receipts, and other documents relating to the collision.
- Preserve Communications – Keep emails, letters, text messages, and other communications with insurance adjusters. Take notes of important telephone conversations, including dates and the subjects discussed.
- Ask Why Your Claim Was Denied or Reduced – If an insurer denies your claim or makes a settlement offer you believe is inadequate, request an explanation. Understanding the insurer’s position can help your attorney determine how to respond.
- Avoid Prematurely Accepting a Settlement – An early settlement may not account for future medical expenses or the full impact of an injury. Do not assume an insurance company’s first offer represents the maximum amount you could recover.
- Consult an Attorney Before Filing a Lawsuit – An attorney can review the accident, insurance coverage, evidence of damages, and the insurer’s conduct. Litigation may be appropriate in some cases, while negotiation or another remedy may be more effective in others.
Should You File an Insurance Complaint in Arizona?
A lawsuit is not the only possible response to an insurance dispute. The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) regulates insurance companies in Arizona and provides a process for consumers to submit insurance-related complaints.
A regulatory complaint and a lawsuit are different things. A DIFI complaint does not substitute for legal advice or necessarily provide the same remedies that may be available through litigation.
If you believe your insurer has mishandled your claim, discussing the circumstances with a Tucson attorney can help you understand your available options.
Do Not Wait Too Long to Pursue an Auto Accident Claim
Under A.R.S. § 12-542, you have two years after the discovery of an injury to file a personal injury claim and related actions, subject to statutory exceptions.
Other deadlines or legal requirements may apply depending on the parties involved and the nature of the claim. Waiting until the deadline is approaching can also make it more difficult to gather evidence, locate witnesses, obtain records, and build a strong case.
It is therefore better to seek legal advice early rather than waiting to see whether an insurance dispute eventually resolves itself.
How a Tucson Auto Accident Attorney Can Help
Dealing with an insurance company after a serious collision can be frustrating, particularly when you are also recovering from your injuries.
A Tucson auto accident attorney can investigate the collision, review the available insurance coverage, assess your damages, communicate with the insurer, evaluate settlement offers, and negotiate on your behalf. If there is no reasonable resolution, your attorney can determine whether litigation is appropriate.
The goal is not simply to file a lawsuit. It is to pursue the legal strategy that gives you the best opportunity to recover the compensation you may be entitled to under Arizona law.
Contact a Tucson Auto Accident Attorney
If an insurance company has denied your car accident claim, delayed payment, disputed your losses, or offered a settlement that does not adequately compensate you, you do not have to navigate the dispute alone.
If you are in Tucson, AZ, talk to Mr. Barry Bellovin of The Bellovin Law Firm. He is an experienced Tucson personal injury attorney and can help you understand your rights, evaluate the insurer’s position, and pursue the strategy that makes sense for your case. Contact his office today to discuss your auto accident and insurance claim.